Review by Jessu

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

Completionist

Finished Nov 1, 2026 · on Linux

This is the best Sherlock Holmes game that I've played in the series. For me this has the best mixture of satisfying exploration, deduction, and great cases. I like most cases in this and I think it's a really smart that they are using multiple cases over one overarching story like in Testament game.

I probably don't know how to describe this accurately, but the way that the game is presented, the vibes, and everything around it really gives you the nostalgic feeling of playing old style point and click games, even though the game is not necessarily a point and click game. It gives you the same feeling though in a positive way.

I also think the voice acting and the model of both Holmes and Watson are also the best version in the series. I love their personality and all their quips.

This is such a great Sherlock Holmes portrayal for a video game, and definitely the best one yet.

0
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments poster

Share this review

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments · by Jessu

This is the best Sherlock Holmes game that I've played in the series. For me this has the best mixture of satisfying exploration, deduction, and great cases....

Comments

Write Your Own Game Reviews

Join Searchtoplay to share your thoughts on games and connect with other players.