Jessu

Member since June 2025
โœ๏ธ Freelance translator, transcriptionist, etc. for English - Indonesian language pair
๐Ÿˆ Cat lovers, cat owners๐Ÿˆ
๐Ÿ—พ Full-time weeby NEET
๐Ÿง Proud Linux user #CachyOS
๐ŸŽฎ๏ธ Video games enthusiast
๐Ÿ”ด Adopted Kopites #LFC
๐Ÿ’ Let's go Oilers!
๐Ÿณ๏ธโ€โšง๏ธ She/Her

I am on the spectrum, so please excuse my shortcomings.
Unfinished
Finished Nov 05, 2026 on Linux

What the actual fuck is even this game? This is just random detective game with Sherlock Holmes name spray all over it.

Despite the game looking really good compared to previous Sherlock Holmes games, unfortunately the game is anything but. Unsatisfying deduction with purposefully "open-ended" outcome and the lack of "absolute truth" for some people can be perceived as "freedom of choice and build your own narrative". For me, it's laziness and incompetent.

Very simple example is the prologue case where you have 2 possible suspect, then you found a a great clue for your deduction such as scratch mark caused by the employees. What's the logical path? Interview the people involved to get the truth. Yet you can't even ask the employee for a follow-up to know if the incident actually occurred, you can only GUESS AND MAKE ASSUMPTIONS and be adamant that "my truth is the truth". Such an egotistical approach that lack common sense. You don't even need to be a detective to be able to inquire something as simple as that. Such a lazy game design.

I tried to keep going but then you introduced.... combat??? For a second I genuinely thought I was playing Mafia. What a load of BS. A prime example of game devs adding features for the sake of adding features. Incapable of creating better writing and/or level design, so just add a lot of stuff to make up for it.

Truly the worst Sherlock Holmes game I've ever played. Worse in all aspect compared to their predecessors. Waste of time, waste of money.

Such a disgrace that the name Sherlock Holmes was used in vain.

Completionist
Finished Nov 03, 2026 on Linux

This is a bit complicated game to talk about. Personally, this game is worse than Crimes and Punishment in a lot of ways. There are things I like about the game, but there are at least equal numbers of things that I dislike about it. I like that the game is basically a sequel story-wise to Testament. At the same time I feel that they are taking quite a radical direction with the game as well.

In general, I like the cases present in the game. I still think they are weaker compared to those in Crimes and Punishment, but it's not bad. The first case was good, the second one is better but then it turns into a weird ending. It goes downhill afterwards unfortunately. I just strongly dislike the paranormal side of it. The hallucinations and visions is just so out of the blue (maybe not in hindsight as they ended up making Lovecraftian game after this).

I have quite a strong reaction to this version of Sherlock Holmes model. I don't know why they are making Holmes and Watson look very young here, and it is quite jarring if you have played Testament and Crimes and Punishment. I really don't vibe with this younger model. The voice is also not bad, but it's just not as great as the last one. I truly prefer the previous version. Although you can get used to it in the long run as it is not bad at all, it's just different.

Last but not least, the gameplay is the bane of this game for me. Somehow I feel like they are obsessed with the gimmick-y minigames and stuff, making the game feel tedious instead of stimulating. I really wished they gave us more puzzle rather than more QTEs. It feels so cheap and lazy for a game design especially when it is supposed to be a Sherlock Holmes game. And yet when we talk about puzzle, the quality is quite a slippery slope yet again if we compared it to Crimes and Punishment. There are good ones, but there are bad ones, and the bad ones can be quite frustrating. Sometimes the puzzles feels lacking of logical thinking and the deductions rely more on ambiguity for the sake of "branching ending" of the case.

Ironically, this game is substantially more popular. Maybe it's because the game is just more modern and newer.

If you have played Testament and you are quite a hardcore Sherlock Holmes fans, you might as well play this game. But judging the game as a standalone game, I am quite disappointed in it.

Completionist
Finished Oct 20, 2026 on Linux

The game is surprisingly good.

I really enjoyed the story for the most part. After playing previous Sherlock Holmes games that I just can't stick with due to the frustrating outdated gameplay, this game addressed most of my complaints from those games. It's still not perfect, but it is still the best one yet looking at it chronologically. When I can look past these issues and excusing the age of the game, the game is really enjoyable. Shame the fps is capped at 60.

I truly enjoyed how the game gives you choice to play it in 3 different perspectives: first person, third person, and classic point and click. I really liked the idea and the implementation. There's only one specific point in the game where I overlooked an item because it was quite well hidden if you are playing it on third person perspective. Other than that, everything works well.

One thing to note though, I don't know why but I have experienced this issue since the past Sherlock Holmes game that already implemented the first person perspective, whenever I play on first person it makes me want to puke. There's something in this game that doesn't sit well with me and every time I use the first person perspective it caused motion sickness. I am not sure why as I have played hundreds of games using first person perspective since I was a kid.

Most puzzles are good, really fun and satisfying. Some can be really challenging and make your brain gear moving. Although there are moments here and there where the puzzle felt arbitrary and/or explained poorly. I think this is yet another thing that were just overlooked at the time. I hope the next game I play in this series are better at it.

Voice acting in this game also has its own charms. It's not great, but it felt perfect for the game. It's just quite charming and make the game richer.

If you can live with some of the old game design this game suffered from, it's a really fun experience.

Completionist
Finished Oct 18, 2026 on Linux

Decades of playing JRPG, countless of remastered and remake, and thought I have seen it all. Proven wrong last year with Trails 1st Chapter, and proven wrong yet again by 2nd Chapter.

This is the best game Falcom ever made. I still can't believe that a remake would become one of, if not, the best JRPG I have ever played. Amazing throughout, from top to bottom. What an amazing game. The quality of every single aspect is just so wonderful. Animation, music, voice acting, story, gameplay, all of them crafted with so much attention and love. It truly felt like a love letter for the fans.

For those who have played the original game, we already knew the story, but the game just perfectly retell the story and even if you have played the original game it still hits you nevertheless. One of the biggest aspect on why it works is that now we are relieving the story with a full blown 3D animation and also dubbed by amazing performances by the Japanese voice actors.

The original music was great, but now retouched with rearrangement and it became an amazing masterpiece.

The gameplay is as creative and tight as always. Using their staple of orbment system, but also mixed with newer quick battle system, truly brings out the richness of the game. I genuinely think that this is the best gameplay in Trails entries. I love this combat system the most. QoL is also a huge point of the game as a step to modernize the game, although I am still missing one feature that I think Trails game should have which is orbment presets as we might want to tweak our orbments setup throughout the game.

Masterpiece. One of my favourite JRPG I've ever played. A remake that's so easily loved by fans of the original series and new players alike. I am truly happy that more people are getting into this franchise.

Main plus extras
Finished Sep 03, 2026 on Linux

This is one of those games where I really had fun with but hesitant to recommend, especially on the current state of the game + full price.

First, the good stuff. The turn-based tactics is just the bread and butter of games like these. The gameplay is really enjoyable. I enjoyed the ever evolving mechanics throughout the game. But what really surprised me is the crewmates. Ever since the first few hours of the game, I keep thinking about Mass Effect and how this game really make me feel the same way to some extent. I think they are inspired by it because you can feel the DNA throughout the game. I wish we could've gotten more core teammates that has their own stories though. I enjoyed the side stories more than the main story. The main story is okay, just not great. I did enjoy the final 20% of the game though, I think it has more interesting late game story. I also enjoyed the voiceover.

Now, the cons that makes me not recommending this game.
- Poor performance. It runs heavily even on decent PC.
- Weird face animation for the main character. I think they should've used a pre-made character because everyone looks fine except the main character. The best way I can describe it is it looks like Mass Effect Andromeda facial animation.
- The game can feel PAINFULLY SLOW on some parts. Some animations are dragged on for too long like when you defeat a Coil enemy, they will transfer their stuff to the others but it takes a solid 10 seconds EACH, and that's if your game is not randomly stay still like it's thinking what to do next because it does happen sometimes too.
- As said on my previous point, the game sometimes just stay still. It's not frozen, the game is running and the idle animation is there, but everything just stay still. The game is like struggling to think what to do next.
- The game could do with some QoL features, such as fast forward or skip animation, or undo move because sometimes you unknowingly do what you don't wanna do because the game can be weird with the control.
- Inconsistent camera. Sometimes you can see the playing field amazingly, then the next time you are ZOOMED IN and can't zoom out anymore because apparently that's how the intended experiences are.